Blend Repairs on Machined Fittings and Forgings: Ratio, Finish and Protection

A blend removes a defect from a machined fitting or a forging and leaves a smooth dish with no sharp root. This guide gives the ratio, the finish and the protection the public documents print, the care for steel and aluminum, and what the manual for the part decides.

View PDF

1Identification

Where to buy

The drawing

A section through a notch and the same surface blended into a smooth dish at twenty to one, the plan of a fitting with the dish elongated along the load, the order of work, what is never done and a parts list
After AC 43.13-1B pars. 6-115, 6-136, 6-165; TO 1-1A-1 (NAVAIR 01-1A-1) pars. 3.11.3.4, 3.12. Generic: the SRM or the drawing gives the blend ratio, depth limit and finish for the part.

What you are blending and why

ItemWhat the sources saySource
Stress concentrationA fatigue crack starts more readily where the design or the surface gives a stress concentration: fillets, sharp radii, a poor surface finish, seams, grinding cracksAC 43.13-1B par. 5-5 e (3); TO 1-1A-1 par. 2.5.2.1
Why a notch is blendedBlending a scratch on load-bearing structure reduces the stress concentration; the SRM gives the blend allowance and the acceptable finishTO 1-1A-1 par. 3.12 and fig. 3-12
Notch-sensitive alloy7075-T6 is more notch sensitive than 2014 and 2024: avoid notches, small radii, machine marks, nicks, dents, burrs and scratchesAC 43.13-1B par. 4-58 b
Tool marks and cornersParts are left free from cracks, tool marks, rough edges and notches caused by cutting or grinding; corners and holes take generous radiiTO 1-1A-1 par. 3.1.1
Flaws already in the partForging laps and bursts, machining tears, heat-treat cracks at fillets and notches, grinding cracks: found by inspection, not by blendingAC 43.13-1B par. 5-5; TO 1-1A-1 pars. 2.5.2.2, 2.5.2.3
Material and heat treatmentFrom the drawing or the SRM. Steel heat-treated above Rockwell C40 (180 000 psi) changes how metal may be removedAC 43.13-1B par. 6-165

Defects that a blend can remove: scratch, nick, gouge, cut, burr and corrosion pit; definitions in the damage classification guide.

2Allowable damage

What the public documents set

ItemPublished ruleSource
Ratio, corrosion dish-outs20 : 1, length to depth, smoothly blended; elliptical, major axis spanwise on wings and horizontal stabilizers, longitudinal on fuselages, vertical on vertical stabilizersAC 43.13-1B par. 6-115 a, c
Ratio and depth, mechanical damage—: the aircraft SRM gives the blend allowance. 20 : 1 is not a general rule for a scratch or nickTO 1-1A-1 par. 3.12
Rework depth limit—: the SRM. Determine the depth of the faired depression to be sure the limit is not exceeded; beyond it the aircraft manufacturer or a DER decidesAC 43.13-1B pars. 6-136 i, 6-134 b
Which pits to blendCritical and highly stressed areas: every pit left after removing the corrosion. Non-critical structure: pits left by blasting need not be blended out, which would only take more metalAC 43.13-1B par. 6-115 b
Surface finishAbrasive paper progressively finer to 400 grit (aluminum); magnesium and steel: 240, then 300, then 400 grit. A roughness value is —: the SRMAC 43.13-1B pars. 6-136 g, 6-152 h, 6-167 h; TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.12
Fillet radius—: the drawing or the SRM. Sharp corners are avoided and radii at holes and edges are generousTO 1-1A-1 par. 3.1.1
CracksA crack in a landing-gear member: the part is replaced. No crack is negligible until the damage limits are known; beyond repair boundaries it goes to engineeringAC 43.13-1B par. 9-4 g; TO 1-1A-1 Table 2-1, par. 3.11.3.6
Small nicks and cutsOn a landing-gear member they can be filed and burnished to a smooth contour, removing the stress concentrationAC 43.13-1B par. 9-4 g
HeatHeavy continuous abrasive grinding can heat the metal enough to change it: if suspected, hardness or conductivity tests. Grinding cracks run at right angles to the grinding direction, shallow and sharp at the rootAC 43.13-1B pars. 6-136, 5-5 d (3)
High-strength steelHeat-treated above Rockwell C40, 180 000 psi: mild abrasive mats, cloths and papers; a power tool is undesirable (overheating, notches); chemical removers are prohibited without engineering authorization (hydrogen embrittlement)AC 43.13-1B par. 6-165
Shot peeningPeening is a way of producing compressive residual stress in a part; the sources print no intensity, coverage or media: —, the manufacturer's drawing or manualAC 43.13-1B par. 6-39; TO 1-1A-1 app. C par. C.11

Every cell stops where the document stops. A cell showing — is a value the SRM or the drawing gives.

3Repair

Step by step

StepActionWhat to do
1Get the limit firstPart, material and the rework limit from the SRM or the drawing. Beyond the SRM limit, the manufacturer or a DER (AC 43.13-1B par. 6-134 b). A crack in a landing-gear member means a new part (par. 9-4 g).
2Inspect before you remove metalClean and look at the defect and its surroundings with a magnifier; NDI as the SRM requires. Grinding cracks and tool marks show up here (AC par. 5-5; TO 1-1A-1 par. 2.5.2).
3Take steel hardware away from aluminumRemove steel nut-plates and steel fasteners before blending aluminum: steel or copper particles embedded in it start new corrosion (AC par. 6-115 c).
4Remove the defect, shape the dishElliptical, long axis along the principal load, length 20 times the depth where the rule is 20 : 1, or the ratio the SRM names. No power tool on steel above 180 000 psi (par. 6-165).
5Finish with finer abrasiveProgressively finer abrasive paper up to 400 grit, or the finish the SRM states. Keep heat out of the part (par. 6-136).
6Measure the depth after finishingAgainst the rework limit. The ratio is for the dish you end up with: if the depth grew during finishing, check the length again (par. 6-136 i).
7Protect it at onceChemical conversion coat immediately after reworking, then primer and finish. Re-apply the conversion coat if 48 hours pass without primer (par. 6-136 j, k; TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.11.3.5).
8Restore the peening and record itWhere the area was peened, the manufacturer gives the peening to restore. Record place, depth, length, ratio, finish, inspection and the SRM reference (14 CFR 43.9).

Blending: the ratio and who sets it

PointWhat each document saysAgree or differ
Blend ratioAC 43.13-1B pars. 6-115 and 6-136 g: smooth blended dish-outs at 20:1, length to depth (Fig. 6-15).
T.O. 1-1A-1 par. 3.12 and Fig. 3-12: blend scratches on load-bearing structure to cut the stress concentration; the allowance and the finish come from the weapon system's structural repair manual.
The AC gives the ratio; the T.O. gives none and sends you to the SRM. Use the SRM's allowance, and 20:1 where it is silent.

AC 43.13-1B CHG 1 pars. 6-115 and 6-136 g and Fig. 6-15; T.O. 1-1A-1 par. 3.12.

Protection after the blend

StepRuleSource
Conversion coatMIL-C-81706 immediately after reworking; if 48 hours or more pass and no primer or paint has gone on, apply it again before going onAC 43.13-1B par. 6-136 j
PrimerEpoxy primer MIL-P-23377 to a minimum dry-film thickness of 0.0012 in (US military repair practice); a manufacturer's system overrides itTO 1-1A-1 par. 3.11.3.5
Where not to use the solutionsNot on magnesium or on steel of 180 000 psi and above: they must not contact those metals; no paint thinner, acetone or other combustible material near themAC 43.13-1B par. 6-136 j (note)
Shot peening—: intensity, coverage and media from the manufacturer's drawing or manualAC 43.13-1B par. 6-39
Health and safetyAlodine and epoxy primer are toxic: eye and skin protection, good general ventilationTO 1-1A-1 par. 3.11.3 (warning)

Worked example: three blends at 20 : 1

CaseArithmeticResult
Scratch 0.012 in deep on a 7075-T6 forged fitting, corrosion rule applied20 × 0.012 = 0.240 in longDish 0.240 in long, 0.012 in deep, long axis along the load; SRM limit: —
Pit 0.030 in deep, critical area20 × 0.030 = 0.600 in0.600 in of dish; all pits left after removal blended out (AC 6-115 b)
Same scratch, depth 0.012 in measured before finishing and 0.018 in after20 × 0.018 = 0.360 in against 0.240 in blendedThe dish is too short: lengthen it to 0.360 in, then measure again
Depth after finishing 0.018 in, SRM rework limit —The limit is the SRM'sInside: finish, coat, record. Beyond: manufacturer or DER (AC 6-134 b)

Arithmetic of the 20 : 1 rule on example sizes. The 20 : 1 ratio is printed for corrosion dish-outs; for a mechanical defect the SRM ratio applies.

What to check when it is done

Look atGoodSource
DefectGone: no trace under magnification or the NDI the SRM calls forAC 43.13-1B par. 6-136 g; TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.11.3.4
ShapeSmooth elliptical dish, no sharp root, no tool marks or ridges, long axis along the loadAC par. 6-115 a; TO par. 3.1.1
DepthInside the rework limit of the SRMAC par. 6-136 i
FinishFinal abrasive pass done, no heat discolorationAC par. 6-136 g
ProtectionConversion coat and primer on, no bare metalAC par. 6-136 j
RecordPosition, size, ratio, finish, inspection, SRM reference14 CFR 43.9

Quick check

A 0.020 in deep pit is blended at 20 : 1. How long is the dish?

  1. 0.400 in

    Best fit. Yes: 20 × 0.020 = 0.400 in, along the load direction.

  2. 0.040 in

    Not this one. No: that is twice the depth.

  3. 0.100 in

    Not this one. No: that is five times the depth.

On a real job, the SRM decides.

Questions people actually ask

Is 20 : 1 the ratio for any blend?

It is the ratio printed for corrosion dish-outs (AC 43.13-1B par. 6-115 c). For a mechanical defect on a fitting the SRM gives ratio and depth limit (TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.12).

How deep may I go?

The public documents give no depth. The SRM sets the rework limit per part; beyond it the manufacturer or a DER decides.

Can I blend out a crack?

Not on a landing-gear member: the part is replaced (AC 43.13-1B par. 9-4 g). Elsewhere a crack is not negligible until its limits are known (TO 1-1A-1 Table 2-1).

Do I have to shot peen again?

If the area was peened, the manufacturer's drawing or manual gives the peening to restore. The sources used here print no intensity or coverage.

Limits of this guide

What the sources support, and no further.

  • The SRM or the drawing governs. Blend ratio, depth limit, roughness and fillet radius for a part are theirs; none is printed in the documents used here.
  • 20 : 1 is the corrosion ratio of AC 43.13-1B, not a rule for every defect.
  • No peening data (intensity, coverage, media) is published here.
  • No roughness value is given: the finish is stated by grit sequence only.
  • Typical, not authority. Methods are examples; the SRM governs.

Where to buy

AmericaDistributor coming soon
EuropeDistributor coming soon
OceaniaDistributor coming soon

Are you a distributor? Get listed →

Distributors coming soon.

Main sources

  • AC 43.13-1B with Change 1, Acceptable Methods, Techniques, and Practices — Par. 4-58 b (7075-T6); par. 5-5 (flaws); par. 6-39 (shot peening); pars. 6-115, 6-134, 6-136 (blending, rework, examples); par. 6-152 h (magnesium); par. 6-165 and 6-167 (steel); par. 9-4 g (landing gear).
  • TO 1-1A-1 / NAVAIR 01-1A-1, General Manual for Structural Repair (15 Jan 2016) — Pars. 2.5.2.1 to 2.5.2.3 (stress concentration, cracks from heat treat and grinding); par. 3.1.1 (corners, tool marks); pars. 3.11.3.4 to 3.11.3.6 (crack repair, protection); par. 3.12 and fig. 3-12 (blending scratches); app. C par. C.11.
  • 14 CFR Part 43, par. 43.9 — Maintenance record content.

Cross-checked with other manuals and standards in our library.

Educational reference only. Not approved data. Always consult the applicable SRM, AMM, or AC 43.13-1B and your certifying authority.
esc
↑↓ navigate↵ openesc close