Fastener Hole Damage: Oversize, Reaming and Bushings

A hole that no longer fits its fastener is repaired in a fixed order: confirm it is allowed, step up the fastener (first oversize, second oversize, next diameter), ream, and recheck edge distance and pitch, because each step moves the minimums. This guide gives the limits the public documents print and says where the SRM takes over.

View PDF

1Identification

Where to buy

The drawing

A plan of a row of rivet holes with one elongated and the next diameter dashed, the edge distance e and the pitch p, a hole ladder from standard to first oversize, second oversize and next diameter drawn to scale, a flanged bushing in section, the order of work, the rivet repair limits and a parts list
After AC 43.13-1B pars. 4-57, 4-60, 7-39 and fig. 4-25; TO 1-1A-1 (NAVAIR 01-1A-1) pars. 3.4.12, C.3, C.8.1; FAA-H-8083-31B pp. 4-34, 4-39, 4-40; NAS618. Generic, ladder to scale: the drawing or the SRM governs.

How a damaged hole shows

DefectHow you find itWhere the rule sits
Elongated or oval holeSheared or popped fasteners, loose rivets, elongated holes and cracks at attachments; chipped or cracked paint round a fastener may mark a failure. Remove one or more rivets next to damaged structure and lookTO 1-1A-1 pars. 2.4.3, 2.4.4; AC 43.13-1B par. 4-52
Hole too large for the fastenerA blind-rivet stem that moves under a 10 lb force on the trimmed stem: any looseness means an oversize holeFAA-H-8083-31B p. 4-40
Enlarged or distorted by removalChiseling a rivet head off probably distorts the hole and damages the skin; drilled-out holes can be enlargedAC 43.13-1B par. 4-52; removing a rivet
Enlarged countersinkThe head no longer sits flush; the countersink is beyond toleranceMIL-R-47196A par. 3.4.2
Scored or heat-marked wallTool marks at 45° or less to the hole axis; discoloration round the hole from machining heatTO 1-1A-1 par. C.8.1 c, d
Crack from the holeSmall skin cracks leading away from fastener holes, frequently fatigueTO 1-1A-1 par. 2.4.3; cracks guide
Worn or elongated bolt hole in a fitting or lugPlay at the bolt; the hole oval in the fittingAC 43.13-1B par. 4-60a(4), fig. 4-25

The type of damage sets the route: an oversize rivet hole goes up a size; an elongated bolt hole in a fitting is replaced or repaired with approved data.

2Allowable damage

Measuring the hole

InstrumentWhat it checksSource
Precision measuring equipment, calibratedDiameter, location, edge distance, roundness and taper; the specific engineering document sets the criteriaTO 1-1A-1 par. C.8.1 b, e
Surface finish gaugeWall roughness against 125 µin or less (drilled) and 63 µin or less (reamed)TO 1-1A-1 par. C.8.1 d
Go/no-go gaugeAccepts the hole, not the drill: Cherry T172-4 for the nominal CherryMAX hole, T172-400 for the oversizeThe Aviation Point data
10-power magnifierScratches, nibbler marks and cracks on a steel fitting: a careful examination with at least 10 power is an acceptable inspectionAC 43.13-1B par. 4-60a(1)
Feeler gauge, 0.005 inHead seat of a blind rivet: not under the head for more than half the circumferenceFAA-H-8083-31B p. 4-40
NDIWhether a hole needs it, and which technique, is set in separate technical directives or engineering documentsTO 1-1A-1 par. C.8.2

What the public documents allow

CaseRuleSource
Bolt holes, military practiceBolt holes should not be oversized or elongated; the first drill size above nominal is used up to 1/2 in, same-size drill aboveTO 1-1A-1 par. 5.2.2.2
Bolt holes, FAA practiceOversized or elongated holes in structural members: reaming or drilling to the next larger bolt size may be permissible, if edge distance, clearance and structural integrity are kept. Consult the SRM, the manufacturer's engineering department or the FAA before drilling or reaming any bolt hole in a critical structural memberAC 43.13-1B par. 7-39
Fitting designed without bushingsElongated or worn bolt holes are not reamed oversize. Replace the fitting, unless the method is approved by the FAA. Do not fill holes with welding rodAC 43.13-1B par. 4-60a(4)
Aluminum fitting, castingReplace with the same material specification; repair only to the maker's data or FAA-approved data. Castings are replaced, not repaired, unless the maker or approved data allows itAC 43.13-1B pars. 4-60b, 4-61
Rivet hole enlarged or damagedDrill or ream for the next larger rivet, if edge distance and spacing stay at or above the minimums. Never replace with a lower-strength rivet unless size or number compensatesAC 43.13-1B par. 4-57b
Oversize repairs in one patternAt most 20 % of the rivets or 10 rivets in a single pattern, whichever is less, counting oversize holes and countersinks together. No more than two adjacent oversize rivets. No more than half the rivets oversize in any 10 in of pattern. Anything more needs written approvalMIL-R-47196A pars. 3.4, 3.4.3 (canceled, superseded by NASM47196)
Next sizeNext larger diameter listed in the drawing's standard, in steps of 1/32 in up to 1/4 in and 1/16 in aboveMIL-R-47196A par. 3.4.2
Margin built in at layoutAdd 1/16 in to the minimum edge distance and pitch, or take the edge from the next rivet size, so the hole can be oversized without breaking the minimumsFAA-H-8083-31B p. 4-34
Cold-worked holeOversize only if the engineering document allows it. Post-sizing removes at most 16 to 21 % of the starting diameter or 0.065 in, whichever is less. Sheet at least 1/5 of the hole diameter thickTO 1-1A-1 pars. C.19, C.20, C.23
Interference of a Hi-Lok in aluminumHole prepared so the maximum interference does not exceed 0.002 inFAA-H-8083-31B p. 4-50

Where a document and the SRM disagree, the SRM or the approved data governs. This table is what the public documents print, not a repair scheme.

Edge distance and pitch after the step up

The ladder only works while the edge and pitch survive it. Going up a size moves the minimums up with it.

Rivet ØEdge, AC (2 D)Edge, TO 1-1A-1 (2 D + 0.06)Edge, MIL-R-47196APitch, AC (3 D)Pitch, TO 1-1A-1 (3.5 D)Pitch, MIL-R-47196A
1/80.2500.3100.219 / 0.2810.3750.4380.500
5/320.3130.3730.281 / 0.3440.4690.5470.563
3/160.3750.4350.344 / 0.3750.5630.6560.688
1/40.5000.5600.438 / 0.5000.7500.8750.875

Inches. AC 43.13-1B par. 4-57c: for single-row rivets edge not less than 2 D and spacing not less than 3 D (double and multiple rows: fig. 4-5); if no deficiency is suspected, copy the original edge and spacing. TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.4.12: edge 2 D plus 0.06 in; protruding-head pitch 3.5 D, flush 4 D. MIL-R-47196A Tables VII and VIII: edge columns A and B / C and D as printed (fig. 2 shows A and B on a plain hole and C on the visible edge of a countersunk hole), and pitch for universal-head rivets. The AC and TO 1-1A-1 columns are arithmetic from the rule; the MIL-R figures are as printed. Three documents, three answers: use the one the repair authority names.

Hole wall and cold-worked holes

ItemLimitSource
SquarenessHole perpendicular to the surface the head seats on within ±3°, unless the drawing says otherwiseTO 1-1A-1 par. C.8.1
Roughness125 µin or less drilled, 63 µin or less reamed; tool marks or scratches at 45° or less to the axis are unsatisfactoryTO 1-1A-1 par. C.8.1 d
DiscolorationAny discoloration round the hole needs engineering evaluationTO 1-1A-1 par. C.8.1 c
Cold-worked hole, edgeIf the engineering document gives no edge margin, 1.75 D or more is recommended (center to edge over finished diameter); spacing at least 3 DTO 1-1A-1 pars. C.16, C.17
Cold-worked hole, acceptanceShear discontinuities and surface upset at the hole are not cause for rejection; abnormal upset goes to engineeringTO 1-1A-1 pars. C.24, C.25
Existing countersinkCold working a hole that already has a countersink gives only marginal fatigue improvement; special procedures existTO 1-1A-1 par. C.22

3Repair

Step by step

StepActionWhat to do
1Get the repair authority firstA hole is not enlarged because it fits the drill. The SRM, the drawing or approved data says whether the member allows it; for a bolt hole in a critical member, AC 43.13-1B par. 7-39 sends you to the SRM, the maker or the FAA before drilling or reaming.
2Measure what the step up will useHole diameter, edge distance and pitch, against the minimums of the document the repair names. The edge distance and rivet spacing calculators do the arithmetic.
3Pick the next fastener in the rangeFirst oversize (1/64 in), second oversize (1/32 in) where the fastener has them, then the next diameter. Tables below. The fastener hole drill gives the drill.
4Pilot, then reamMachine the pilot hole about 0.015 in under the reamer size. Reaming aluminum needs cutting fluid. Take the drill or reamer out of the hole still turning clockwise, so the wall is not scored (TO 1-1A-1 par. C.3 d, g, note to C.7). Large holes: pilot through a drill bushing, step to about 1/64 in under, then finish with a step reamer (FAA-H-8083-31B p. 4-20).
5Deburr and check the wallDeburr with an oversize drill or a deburring tool (AC 43.13-1B par. 4-58). Check roundness, roughness and squareness against the wall limits.
6Treat and primeBare aluminum is recoated at once. Where the rivet is dissimilar to the material, hole, countersink and rivet are coated with zinc chromate primer and the rivet is installed wet (MIL-R-47196A par. 3.5).
7Install and check the seatInstall the fastener of the new size and check it against the checks after the repair.
8Recheck and recordMeasure edge distance and pitch again on the finished hole, count the oversize repairs in the pattern, and record the repair as the repair authority requires.

Solid rivets: the next diameter

Solid rivets go up by the next diameter, never by a drill size alone.

RivetDrill, pilot / finalNext sizeIts drill
3/32 in3/32 in, #40 (0.098)1/8 in#30 (0.1285)
1/8 in1/8 in, #30 (0.1285)5/32 in#21 (0.159)
5/32 in5/32 in, #21 (0.159)3/16 in#11 (0.191)
3/16 in3/16 in, #11 (0.191)7/32 in— the drawing or the SRM gives it
1/4 in1/4 in, F (0.257)9/32 in— the drawing or the SRM gives it

FAA-H-8083-31B fig. 4-90, p. 4-39: drill about 0.003 in over the top of the shank tolerance. The 7/32 and 9/32 in drills are not in the figure. See the drill size for rivets chart for the oversize-shank repair rivets.

Oversize pins and blind rivets: first, second, then next

FastenerStandard hole1st oversize, 1/64 in2nd oversize, 1/32 inNext diameter
Hi-Lok -6, 3/16 in0.1895–0.1905 (col. A)0.2026–0.2036 (col. J), pin HL620.2182–0.2192 (col. R), pin HL218-8: 0.2495–0.2505
Hi-Lok -8, 1/4 in0.2495–0.25050.2651–0.26610.2807–0.2817-10: 0.312–0.313
Hi-Lok -5, 5/32 in0.1635–0.1645None: use the -6 standard pinNone: use the -6 1/64 oversize-6
CherryMAX -4, 1/8 in#30, 0.129–0.132#27, 0.143–0.146None published-5
CherryMAX -5, 5/32 in#20, 0.160–0.164#16, 0.176–0.180None published-6
CherryMAX -6, 3/16 in#10, 0.192–0.196#5, 0.205–0.209None published-8
CherryMAX -8, 1/4 inF, 0.256–0.261I, 0.271–0.275None published—
NAS6200 boltClose-toleranceX: grip portion 1/64 in larger (NAS6204-6X)Second oversize exists; the AC gives no figure—

Hi-Lok: NAS618 sheets 3, 4, 6, 7 (AIA, 1986, reaffirmed 1992), the oversize pin keeps the dash of the pin it replaces; see Hi-Lok holes. CherryMAX: nominal and 1/64 in oversize only (The Aviation Point data); hole limits in inches. NAS6200: AC 43.13-1B par. 7-49, available in two oversized diameters; the elongated hole may have to be reamed to fit. Reamers are available for both clearance and interference hole sizes (FAA-H-8083-31B p. 4-20).

Reaming: tools and speeds

ItemAluminumTitaniumSteel under 260 ksiSource
Drill, maximum rpm900500500TO 1-1A-1 Table C-1
Reamer, maximum rpm700250250TO 1-1A-1 Table C-2
Countersink, counterbore, rpm500150150TO 1-1A-1 Table C-4
Drill to NAS 907Type AType JType JTO 1-1A-1 par. C.5 g, h
Reamer to NAS 897Type A or EType B or FType B or FTO 1-1A-1 par. C.5 k, l
Cutter materialHSS (M1, M7, M10)8 % cobalt HSS, or carbide8 % cobalt HSS; carbide over HRC 50TO 1-1A-1 par. C.5 a–c
Flex honeAluminum oxide, 180 grit, 5 s per pass, 350 rpmSilicon carbide, 120 gritBoron carbide, 180 grit (120 over 220 ksi)TO 1-1A-1 Table C-3

Speeds are for holes up to 0.360 in with hand tools; larger holes are calculated individually. Steels over 260 ksi: engineering instructions. Mixed stacks: the speed and fluid of the harder metal, drilling from the harder side when possible (par. C.3 f). Apply enough pressure for sharp, uniform chips; never let a cutter dwell (par. C.6.3). No feed rate is published.

Interference and light-drive fits

FitWhat is printedSource
Bolt, normalFirst lettered drill size above the nominal bolt diameterAC 43.13-1B par. 7-39
Light-drive (reamed) AN hex boltInterference of 0.0006 in for a 5/8 in bolt; no other size is printedAC 43.13-1B par. 7-39
Close-tolerance boltInterference fit; may need a light tap with a mallet; chilling the bolt in a freezer removes friction, let it return to ambient before torquingAC 43.13-1B par. 7-44
Hi-Lok, Hi-Tigue, lockboltInterference fit in aluminum, not over 0.002 in; clearance fit in steel, titanium and compositeFAA-H-8083-31B pp. 4-50, 4-52
Tapered shank bolt (Taper-Lok)Precision-reamed tapered hole; new installation or rework of the hole by trained personnel; never substituted by another fastener or the reverseFAA-H-8083-31B p. 4-55
Rivets and bolts in one spliceWhen both are used, the bolt holes are reamed accurately to sizeAC 43.13-1B par. 4-58m

The word fit means a hole limit on the drawing or in NAS618. Where this table prints no figure, the drawing or the SRM does.

Bushings and sleeves

CaseWhat the public sources saySource
Fitting designed with no bushingDo not ream it oversize to fit a bolt; replace, unless the method is FAA-approvedAC 43.13-1B par. 4-60a(4)
Elongated or worn bolt hole in a steel strut endThe figure shows a bushing in an elongated lug and, for strut ends, methods A and B: an added 4130 taper washer, thickness not less than 1.5 t and not more than 2 t, with the lug reshaped; parts originally heat treated are reheat treated after weldingAC 43.13-1B fig. 4-25 (landing gear, stabilizer, interplane, cabane strut ends)
Press-fit bushing, interference— no public figure; the SRM or approved data gives interference, wall and flange—
Flanged bushing, flange and wall— no public figure; the SRM or approved data gives them—
Stripped threaded holeDrill out, fit a threaded bushing, retap after bushing. The bushing is pinned or staked in two places about 180° apart. An unflanged bushing sits flush to 0.002 in below the surfaceTO 1-1A-1 par. 3.10
Thread engagement in the bushingAt least one bolt diameter; two diameters for a highly stressed bolt in aluminum or magnesiumTO 1-1A-1 par. 3.10 c

Minimum wall left after drilling and tapping (TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.10 b, as printed): aluminum, magnesium or brass up to 1/2 in OD 0.0937 in, up to 3/4 in 0.125, up to 1-1/4 in 0.1875, up to 2 in 0.500; steel up to 1/2 in 0.100, up to 3/4 in 0.200, up to 1-1/4 in 0.3281, up to 2 in 0.4062. Threaded bushings are for where thread inserts cannot be used (TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.10, note).

Worked example: a 1/8 in rivet hole gone loose

CheckNumberResult
The damage1/8 in universal-head rivet in a single row, hole oval; pitch 0.500 in, edge distance 0.350 inGo up to 5/32 in, drill #21 (0.159)
Edge, AC 43.13-1B par. 4-57c2 × 0.15625 = 0.313 in against 0.350 inPasses
Pitch, AC 43.13-1B par. 4-57c3 × 0.15625 = 0.469 in against 0.500 inPasses
Edge, TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.4.12.12 × 0.15625 + 0.06 = 0.373 in against 0.350 inFails by 0.023 in
Pitch, TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.4.12.23.5 × 0.15625 = 0.547 in against 0.500 inFails
Edge and pitch, MIL-R-47196AEdge, columns A and B, 0.281 in against 0.350; pitch 0.563 in against 0.500Edge passes, pitch fails
Count in the patternOne oversize in a 30-rivet row: 20 % is 6, less than 10, so the cap is 6Within the cap, if no neighbor is already oversize
DecisionThe same hole passes one document and fails two: the repair authority names the rule, and the SRM can still say noSRM, drawing or approved data decides

Arithmetic from the rules printed in the table above; the example numbers are chosen to show the disagreement, not taken from an aircraft.

What to check when it is done

Look atAcceptSource
HoleInside the fastener's hole limits; edge distance and pitch re-measured above the minimumsTO 1-1A-1 par. C.8.1 b; AC 43.13-1B par. 4-57c
WallSquare to ±3°, 63 µin or better if reamed, no discolorationTO 1-1A-1 par. C.8.1
SeatHead tight; for a blind rivet, 0.005 in feeler not under the head for over half the circumference and the trimmed stem tight at 10 lbFAA-H-8083-31B p. 4-40
FinishHole treated and primed before the fastener goes inTO 1-1A-1 par. 2.4; MIL-R-47196A par. 3.5
PatternOversize repairs inside the 20 % or 10 limit, none more than two adjacentMIL-R-47196A par. 3.4.3
RecordsLocation, old and new hole, fastener part number, edge distance and the repair authority's reference. The record format is the operator's—

Quick check

How many oversize rivet repairs does MIL-R-47196A allow in a single pattern without written approval?

  1. At most 20 % of the rivets or 10, whichever is less

    Best fit. Yes: par. 3.4.3, counting oversize holes and countersinks together.

  2. As many as edge distance allows

    Not this one. No: edge distance is a separate condition, not the count.

  3. One per row

    Not this one. Not what the specification says.

On a real job, the SRM decides.

Questions people actually ask

Can I ream an elongated bolt hole in a fitting?

Not if the fitting was designed without bushings: AC 43.13-1B par. 4-60a(4) says replace it unless the FAA approves the method. In other structural members the next larger bolt size may be permissible, after the SRM, the maker or the FAA has been consulted for a critical member (par. 7-39).

How many times can I oversize a hole?

The public documents do not give one number for every structure. The fastener's own range runs first oversize, second oversize, next diameter; the SRM says how far a member may go, and MIL-R-47196A caps the share of oversize rivets in a pattern.

Why does the next diameter fail on edge distance?

The minimum edge distance and pitch grow with the diameter. FAA-H-8083-31B p. 4-34 advises adding 1/16 in at layout so a hole can be oversized later.

Is a bushing the answer for a worn hole?

Sometimes. The public sources show a bushing or washer repair for steel strut ends (AC 43.13-1B fig. 4-25) and a threaded bushing for stripped threads (TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.10). Interference, wall and flange of a press-fit bushing come from the SRM.

Limits of this guide

What the sources support, and no further.

  • The SRM governs. Every limit here is what a public document prints; the aircraft's SRM or the approved data overrides it.
  • No press-fit or flanged bushing figures are published: interference, wall and flange come from the SRM.
  • No general maximum of hole oversize steps for a member is published.
  • MIL-R-47196A is canceled (superseded by NASM47196). It is used here for the repair limits it prints; its tables have printing errors that are not copied.
  • Three rule sets for edge and pitch (AC, TO 1-1A-1, MIL-R) give different numbers; none of them replaces the drawing.
  • Drills for oversize-shank repair rivets (NAS1241, NAS1242) are not in a public table and are not given here.
  • Composite: holes in composite are not covered by the sources used here.
  • Page references are to the printed pages of the editions named in Sources.

Where to buy

AmericaDistributor coming soon
EuropeDistributor coming soon
OceaniaDistributor coming soon

Are you a distributor? Get listed →

Distributors coming soon.

Main sources

  • AC 43.13-1B CHG 1, Acceptable Methods, Techniques, and Practices: Aircraft Inspection and Repair — Par. 4-52 (rivet removal); 4-57 b, c (rivet replacement, edge distance, spacing, figs. 4-4, 4-5); 4-58 (deburring, splices, m); 4-60, 4-61 and fig. 4-25 (fittings, worn bolt holes); 7-39 (bolt fit); 7-44 (close tolerance); 7-49 (NAS6200).
  • FAA-H-8083-31B, Aviation Maintenance Technician Handbook: Airframe, chapter 4 — P. 4-20 (drilling large holes); p. 4-34 (layout margin); p. 4-39 and fig. 4-90 (drill sizes); p. 4-40 (rivet looseness, seating); p. 4-50 (Hi-Lok interference); p. 4-52 (lockbolt hole); p. 4-55 (tapered shank bolts).
  • TO 1-1A-1 / NAVAIR 01-1A-1, General Manual for Structural Repair (15 Jan 2016) — Pars. 2.4.3, 2.4.4 (inspection); 3.4.12 (edge, spacing); 3.10 (threaded bushings); 5.2.2.2 (bolt hole size); appendix C, pars. C.3 to C.8 and C.16 to C.25, Tables C-1 to C-5 (hole quality, cold working).
  • MIL-R-47196A(MI), 6 Sep 1977 (canceled; superseded by NASM47196) — Pars. 3.4 to 3.4.3, 3.5; Tables VII and VIII; fig. 2.
  • NAS618 (AIA), sheets 3, 4, 6, 7 — Hi-Lok hole columns A, J and R; 1986, reaffirmed 1992.
  • The Aviation Point data — CherryMAX nominal and 1/64 in oversize, T172 gauges, drills and hole limits.

Cross-checked with other manuals and standards in our library.

Educational reference only. Not approved data. Always consult the applicable SRM, AMM, or AC 43.13-1B and your certifying authority.
esc
↑↓ navigate↵ openesc close