Airframe Structures: How the Load Goes, and Why the Repair Must Keep It

A repair has to keep the load where the designer put it. Before you touch a member, know what it carries, which class the SRM gives it and how the type was certified: safe-life, fail-safe or damage tolerant. Those three decide the limit, the repair and the inspection that follows it.

View PDF

1Identification

Where to buy

The members and what they carry

MemberWhat it doesSource
Skin (stressed skin)Carries part of the flight and ground loads with the spars, ribs, frames and stringers; its thickness changes with the load at each placeFAA-H-8083-31B pp. 1-9, 1-16
Former, frame, ringGive the fuselage its shape; the heaviest sit where concentrated loads and fittings come in. Makers' names differpp. 1-7, 1-8
BulkheadShape and concentrated loads, like the heaviest frames. At the wing root, the butt rib is also called the compression or bulkhead ribpp. 1-7, 1-15
LongeronRuns across several frames and helps the skin carry the primary bending loads; one piece or built upp. 1-8
StringerLighter and more numerous; gives shape and holds the skin. With the longerons it keeps tension and compression from bending the fuselagep. 1-8
Web members, gussetsVertical or diagonal bracing between longerons and stringers; a gusset is a connecting bracket that adds strengthpp. 1-8, 1-9
SparMain spanwise member of the wing: I-beam, with or without stiffeners, or sine-wave web; some are built fail-safepp. 1-12, 1-13
RibChordwise member giving the airfoil shape; nose and false ribs ahead of and behind the sparspp. 1-14, 1-15
Beams, struts, bars, tie rodsIn a truss every member carries tension or compression; in a wing truss, drag and anti-drag wires (tie rods) resist chordwise loadspp. 1-7, 1-15
Wing struts, jury strutsA semicantilever wing passes part of its load through external struts or wires; short jury struts steady long strutsp. 1-10
Wing attach fittingsAt the inboard end of the spars: the strong, secure attachment to the fuselage, under removable root fairingsp. 1-15
EmpennageStabilizers are built much like wings; the tail cone is lighter because it receives less stressp. 1-21
Floor beams and floor panels—: their loads and limits are in the aircraft SRM. The handbook lists them among composite applicationsp. 7-1
DoublerReinforcing plate riveted under the skin, as behind a flush patch or a cut-outFAA-H-8083-31B ch. 4

Page numbers are FAA-H-8083-31B. The manufacturer's names govern: one maker's ring is another's frame (p. 1-8).

How it is built

ConstructionWho carries the loadSource
TrussWelded steel tube, or riveted aluminum, members carry tension and compression; usually fabric coveredFAA-H-8083-31B p. 1-7
MonocoqueThe skin carries the primary stresses; formers, frames and bulkheads only give shape. Strength for the weight is its problemp. 1-7
SemimonocoqueSkin with longerons, stringers, frames and bulkheads. No single piece is failure critical, so it can take considerable damage. Most modern aircraft, nearly all pressurized onespp. 1-7 to 1-9
Reinforced shellThe skin is reinforced by a complete frameworkp. 1-9
Full cantilever / semicantilever wingNo external bracing / external struts or wiresp. 1-10
Monospar, multispar, box beamOne main spar, several, or two main spars joined by bulkheads; transport aircraft often use the box beampp. 1-11, 1-12
Stressed-skin and wet wingThe skin shares the load; with sealed joints the structure itself is the fuel tankp. 1-16
Honeycomb panelsUsed as skin on stressed-skin wingsp. 1-17

The five stresses

StressWhat it isSource
TensionResists a force that pulls apart. Tensile strength (psi) = breaking load (lb) ÷ cross-section (sq in)FAA-H-8083-31B p. 1-6
CompressionResists a crushing force; shortens or squeezes the partp. 1-6
TorsionTwisting; torsional strength is the resistance to itp. 1-6
ShearOne layer sliding over the next. Riveted plates in tension put the rivets in shear; shear strength is usually equal to or less than tensile or compressive strengthp. 1-6
BendingA combination: compression on the inside of the bend, tension on the outsidep. 1-6
Stress and strainStress is the internal resistance to a load; strain is the deformation it causespp. 1-5, 1-6
PressurizationCycling from unpressurized to pressurized on every flight causes metal fatiguep. 1-9

Members are mostly designed for end loads (tension or compression) rather than side loads (bending). The handbook asks the technician to understand them so as not to change the original design by an improper repair (p. 1-5).

Members and stresses

Semimonocoque fuselage. View A, section looking forward: skin (1), frame (2), longerons (4), Z stringers (5) and a floor beam (7). View B, side with the skin off: frames, a bulkhead (3), stringers, a longeron and a gusset (6), with the FWD arrow. Right: tension, compression, torsion, shear and bending drawn as arrows on a bar; bending puts compression inside the bend and tension outside. Parts list with what each member does, after FAA-H-8083-31B chapter 1.
No single piece is failure critical in a semimonocoque structure: skin, frames, longerons and stringers share the load, so a repair restores the member it cuts and the path that member carried. Floor beam loads and limits are in the aircraft SRM.

Structural classification

ClassMeaningSource
Primary structure; principal structural element (PSE)Contributes significantly to carrying flight, ground or pressurization loads. The certification evaluation identifies the elements whose failure could be catastrophic. Example: highly loaded skins and the understructureAMC 25.571 par. 4; 14 CFR 25.571(a); TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.11.2
Secondary structureCarries less load. The example given is fairings, whose cracks go to the maintenance officer for appraisal; cowlings and fairings need shape more than strengthTO 1-1A-1 par. 3.11.2; FAA-H-8083-31B p. 1-7
Tertiary structure—: named in the Part-66 syllabus, not defined in the documents used here. The aircraft SRM gives the class of each partEASA Part-66 App. I, module 11.2
Single load pathThe load goes through one memberAMC 25.571 par. 4
Multiple load pathThe load is spread through redundant membersAMC 25.571 par. 4

The SRM, not the look of the part, decides its class, and the allowable damage follows the class and the zone.

Safe-life, fail-safe, damage tolerance

ConceptMeaningSource
Safe-lifeA number of flights, landings or hours during which there is a low probability that fatigue cracking takes the strength below design. The part must reach it without detectable cracks, with scatter factors. Used where damage tolerance is impracticalAMC 25.571 par. 4; 14 CFR 25.571(c)
Fail-safeAfter the failure or partial failure of one PSE the structure keeps its required residual strength for a period of unrepaired use. Example: a spar made of two spliced halves; if one breaks, the other carries the loadAMC 25.571 par. 4; FAA-H-8083-31B p. 1-13
Damage toleranceThe structure keeps its required residual strength with fatigue, corrosion or accidental damage present, until an inspection finds it. Those inspections go into the Airworthiness Limitations sectionAMC 25.571 par. 4; 14 CFR 25.571(a)(3), (b)
Widespread fatigue damage (WFD)Cracks at many details at once, big and dense enough that the structure no longer meets its residual strength. MSD: in the same element; MED: in adjacent elementsAMC 25.571 par. 4
Limit of validity (LOV)Flight cycles or hours, or both, up to which it is shown that WFD will not occur; the maintenance program is valid up to it14 CFR 25.571(b); AMC 25.571 par. 4; AC 120-104

These are the transport-category rules (14 CFR Part 25, CS-25). The certification basis of each type decides which apply.

2Allowable damage

Why the class and the philosophy set the limit

The same scratch can be negligible in one place and a repair in another, because the members do not carry the same load. TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.11.2 sends a crack in a fairing to the maintenance officer for appraisal, and requires a crack in highly loaded skin or understructure to be repaired to the system's repair manual, with its allowable damage charts by structure.

In damage-tolerant structure the inspection is part of the design. A repair changes the structure the inspection was planned for, so it may need its own damage-tolerance inspection (AC 120-93; see damage classification) and, on a pressurized fuselage, a repair assessment (AC 120-73).

A semimonocoque structure tolerates damage because no single piece is failure critical (FAA-H-8083-31B p. 1-9). That is a property of the intact structure, not an allowance for the damage you found.

Aging aircraft and corrosion programs

ProgramWhat it doesSource
Continuing structural integrity programThe frame for the others: supplemental inspections, repairs and alterations, mandatory modifications, corrosion prevention and control, repair assessmentAC 91-56B par. 5g(1); AMC 20-20B sect. 5
SSID / SSIPThe damage-tolerance-based inspection program: supplemental structural inspection document and Airworthiness Limitations inspectionsAMC 20-20B sect. 6 and app. 1; AC 91-56B par. 1
SB review, mandatory modificationStructural service bulletins reviewed; the modifications needed for continued airworthiness made mandatoryAC 91-56B par. 8; AMC 20-20B app. 3, annex 4
CPCPA systematic approach to prevent and control corrosion; the aim is to keep it at Level 1 or betterAMC 20-20B sect. 9 and app. 4; AC 91-56B par. 9
Repairs and modificationsDamage-tolerance evaluation of repairs and changes; repair assessment of pressurized fuselagesAMC 20-20B sect. 7; AC 120-93; AC 120-73 (14 Dec 2000)
LOV and WFDWFD evaluation, and the limit of validity of the maintenance programAMC 20-20B sect. 8; AC 120-104

On the hangar floor these arrive as tasks with their own method and interval: SSIDs, SBs and ADs name the NDI method (AC 43.13-1B pars. 5-1, 5-6). The corrosion levels are defined in the type's CPCP.

Alignment and symmetry checks

ItemWhat the handbook saysSource
WhenDihedral and incidence after hard landings or abnormal flight loads, to show nothing is distortedFAA-H-8083-31B p. 2-48
BeforeJack and level the aircraft; weight and loading as the manual says, never above the maximum jacking weight; in a closed hangar, or nose into windpp. 2-47, 2-48
LevelingSpirit level and straight edge on the leveling pegs or blocks; on large aircraft, a grid plate and plumb bobp. 2-47
The checksWing dihedral and incidence, fin verticality, engine alignment, symmetry, stabilizer incidence and dihedralp. 2-48
DihedralThe maker's boards, or a straight edge and inclinometer, at the specified positions, normally on the front sparp. 2-48
IncidenceAt least two positions on the wing, to show it is free from twistp. 2-48
Fin verticalityFrom set points on each side of the fin top to set points on each stabilizer; similar within limitspp. 2-48, 2-49
SymmetrySteel tape between the checkpoints, with a spring scale for equal tension: about 5 lb [22 N] pull. Large aircraft: plumb bobs and chalk marks on the floorp. 2-49
Tolerances—The aircraft's maintenance or service manual (p. 2-49)

The checks after a heavy landing or flight through turbulence are on Inspections after abnormal events.

Fail-safe spar and symmetry check

Section A: a spar made of two halves spliced at the web with plates and fasteners; a crack in the lower cap while the upper half still carries the load. View B: aircraft in plan, FWD up, steel tape from the left and right wing tip checkpoints to an aft point on the center line, L compared with R; about 5 lb (22 N) pull on the tape. Table: safe-life, fail-safe and damage tolerance with their 14 CFR 25.571 and AMC 25.571 references.
Fail-safe means a second load path: one half can break and the other keeps the residual strength. A symmetry check compares L with R after a hard landing or abnormal flight loads; the tolerance for each pair of checkpoints is in the aircraft manual, not here.
Measure it. A hard landing can bend a wing or a stabilizer without a visible crack. The dihedral, incidence and symmetry checks find it; the checkpoints, figures and tolerances are the aircraft manual's (FAA-H-8083-31B pp. 2-48, 2-49).

3Repair

Before a structural repair

StepActionWhat to do
1Locate itStation, buttock line, water line and zone, in the maker's system (locating damage).
2Name the member and its classFrom the SRM, with the allowable damage chart for that structure (TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.11.2).
3Trace the load pathWhat the member carries and which neighbors take its load now; inspect them as well.
4Keep the original designRestore the strength without changing the design (FAA-H-8083-31B p. 1-5): repair principles, splices, patches.
5Restore the protectionConversion coat, primer and sealant (finish, sealing, corrosion).
6Plan the inspectionsDamage-tolerance inspection of the repair where the program asks for it (AC 120-93); repair assessment on a pressurized fuselage (AC 120-73); the NDI method from the procedure (NDI methods).
7RecordLocation, member, data used and the inspections that follow (14 CFR 43.9).

Worked example: reading a symmetry check

After a hard landing the manual calls for a symmetry check. The numbers are drawn for the format; the real checkpoints and tolerances are the aircraft's.

  1. The manual gives a checkpoint on each wing tip and one on the fuselage center line aft. Measure each wing point to the aft point with a steel tape and a spring scale at about 5 lb [22 N], the same pull on both sides (FAA-H-8083-31B p. 2-49).
  2. Left: 312 1/4 in. Right: 312 1/2 in. Difference: 1/4 in = 0.250 in [6.4 mm].
  3. Compare with the manual's tolerance for that pair: —, the manual sets it. Within it, record the figures and go on to cable tension and surface travel (p. 2-49). Outside it, the aircraft is not symmetrical: the manual's procedure and engineering decide what follows.

A 1/4 in [6.4 mm] difference is a number, not a verdict: the tolerance for that pair of checkpoints in the aircraft manual decides.

Syllabus EASA Part-66 Appendix I (as amended by Regulation (EU) 2023/989): 11.2 Airframe structures (ATA 51): (a) general concepts, (b) airworthiness requirements for structural strength, (c) construction methods; 7.18(b) General repair methods — structural repair manual, in part. FAA-S-ACS-1: AM.II.D Airframe Inspection, where it applies.

Quick check

A spar is made of two halves spliced together, so that if one cracks the other still carries the load. Which concept is that?

  1. Safe-life

    Not this one. No: a safe-life part must reach its life without detectable cracks (14 CFR 25.571(c)); it does not count on another member.

  2. Fail-safe

    Best fit. Yes: another part of the structure takes the load of the failed member (FAA-H-8083-31B p. 1-13; AMC 25.571 par. 4).

  3. Monocoque

    Not this one. No: monocoque relies on the skin, with no other bracing (FAA-H-8083-31B p. 1-7).

On a real job, the SRM decides.

Questions people actually ask

Is a fairing primary or secondary structure?

Fairings are the secondary-structure example of TO 1-1A-1 par. 3.11.2. The SRM of the type gives the class of each part, and that is the one that counts.

Fail-safe or damage tolerance: what is the difference?

Fail-safe: residual strength after one PSE has failed, for a period of unrepaired use. Damage tolerance: residual strength with damage present until an inspection finds it, so the inspections are part of the design (AMC 25.571 par. 4; 14 CFR 25.571(a)(3)).

Who sets the inspection thresholds and intervals?

They come from the damage-tolerance evaluation of the type and go into the Airworthiness Limitations section (14 CFR 25.571(a)(3)). The task that reaches the hangar, from an SSID, SB or AD, names the NDI method (AC 43.13-1B pars. 5-1, 5-6).

What is the LOV?

The limit of validity of the maintenance program: the flight cycles or hours up to which it is shown that widespread fatigue damage will not occur (14 CFR 25.571(b); AC 120-104).

Why are nearly all pressurized aircraft semimonocoque?

Pressure cycling on every flight causes fatigue, and the semimonocoque spreads the load so that no single piece is failure critical (FAA-H-8083-31B p. 1-9).

Limits of this guide

What the sources support, and no further.

  • The SRM governs. Class, allowable damage and repair of each part are the type's.
  • No tolerances for alignment or symmetry are given: the maintenance manual has them.
  • Damage-tolerance terms are those of the transport-category rules; other types may have another basis.
  • Tertiary structure is not defined in the documents used here.
  • Corrosion levels are defined in each type's CPCP; they are not restated here.
  • mm and N values are converted from the inch and pound values of the documents.

Where to buy

AmericaDistributor coming soon
EuropeDistributor coming soon
OceaniaDistributor coming soon

Are you a distributor? Get listed →

Distributors coming soon.

Main sources

  • FAA-H-8083-31B, Aviation Maintenance Technician Handbook — Airframe (2023) — Ch. 1, pp. 1-5 to 1-17 and 1-21 (stresses, fuselage and wing construction, fail-safe spar, empennage); ch. 2, pp. 2-47 to 2-49 (structural alignment, symmetry check); ch. 4 (doubler); p. 7-1 (floor beams).
  • 14 CFR 25.571, Damage-tolerance and fatigue evaluation of structure — Pars. (a), (a)(3), (b) and (c).
  • EASA CS-25, AMC 25.571 — Par. 4: definitions of damage tolerance, fail-safe, safe-life, PSE, single and multiple load path, WFD, MSD, MED, LOV.
  • FAA AC 91-56B, Continuing Structural Integrity Program for Airplanes (7 March 2008) — Par. 5g(1), the elements besides the SSIP; par. 8, mandatory modification; par. 9, CPCP; par. 10, repair assessment; par. 4, AC 120-73 and AC 120-93 with their dates.
  • EASA AMC 20-20B, Continuing structural integrity program — AMC-20 Amendment 22 (ED Decision 2021/007/R): sections 5 to 9; appendix 1, SSIP; appendix 3 and its annex 4, service bulletin review; appendix 4, CPCP.
  • FAA AC 120-73, Damage Tolerance Assessment of Repairs to Pressurized Fuselages (14 December 2000) — Repair assessment.
  • FAA AC 120-93, Damage Tolerance Inspections for Repairs and Alterations (2007) — Damage-tolerance inspections of repairs.
  • FAA AC 120-104, Establishing and Implementing Limit of Validity to Prevent Widespread Fatigue Damage — LOV and WFD.
  • TO 1-1A-1 / NAVAIR 01-1A-1, General Manual for Structural Repair — Par. 3.11.2: cracks in primary and secondary structure.
  • AC 43.13-1B with Change 1 — Pars. 5-1 and 5-6: the documents that name the NDI method.
  • 14 CFR Part 43, par. 43.9 — Maintenance record content.
  • EASA Part-66 Appendix I (Regulation (EU) 2023/989) and FAA-S-ACS-1 — Modules 11.2 and 7.18(b); AM.II.D.

Cross-checked with other manuals and standards in our library.

Educational reference only. Not approved data. Always consult the applicable SRM, AMM, or AC 43.13-1B and your certifying authority.
esc
↑↓ navigate↵ openesc close