NDI Methods: What Each One Finds, and What It Misses

About 80 percent of all NDI is done by eye. Every other method sees one kind of flaw in one kind of material: penetrant only what is open to the surface, magnetic particle only iron and steel, eddy current only conductive metal, X-ray hardly ever a delamination. Use the method the manual names, know what it cannot see, and take the accept limits from the NDT manual and the SRM.

View PDF

1Identification

Where to buy

What each method finds and misses

MethodFindsMisses, or limitsMaterialsSource
Visual, with light, mirror and magnifierSurface cracks, corrosion, contamination, finish damage; buckled, bulging or dented skin; overheating marks; composite delamination signsSurface only; generally only large flaws; scratches can be misread as cracksAllAC 43.13-1B pars. 5-15, 5-18 h; table 5-1
BorescopeInside closed structure and engines: pitting, scoring, cracks, seal and part fit, foreign objectsSurface only, and only what the tip can seeAllAC 43.13-1B par. 5-17
Tap testDelamination or disbond near the surface; thin skin to stiffener bondlines; honeycomb with thin face sheetsSkins under 0.080 in [2.0 mm] only; the far bondline of a honeycomb panel needs access from the other side; no record; design details change the soundComposite and bonded metalAC 43.13-1B par. 5-105; FAA-H-8083-31B p. 7-15
Liquid penetrantDiscontinuities open to the surfaceNothing below the surface; rough or porous surfaces; finish and sealant must come off; smeared metal can close the openingNonporous metals and non-metals, steel includedAC 43.13-1B pars. 5-60, 5-63 g; table 5-1
Magnetic particleCracks, laps, seams, voids, pits at or slightly below the surfaceOnly iron and steel; a flaw parallel to the field; paint or chrome over 0.003 in [0.08 mm]; the part must be demagnetized afterFerromagnetic onlyAC 43.13-1B pars. 5-40, 5-41 a, 5-45 a; table 5-1
Eddy currentSurface and subsurface cracks, pits, metal loss from corrosion on inner surfaces; usually through primer, paint and anodic filmConductive material only; the probe must reach the surface; rough surfaces; slow over large areas; best on small local areasElectrically conductiveAC 43.13-1B pars. 5-25, 5-27, 5-30; table 5-1
Eddy current, conductivityAlloy and heat-treat condition; heat damage after grinding, fire or overheatingAcceptance values: the NDT manual or the material specification sets themConductive metalsAC 43.13-1B pars. 5-25, 6-136; TO 1-1A-1 par. 2.1.4
UltrasonicCracks, porosity, delaminations, bond voids; thickness from one sideNeeds couplant and an accessible surface; very sensitive to beam and flaw orientation; high skill to set up and readWide range of materials and thicknessesAC 43.13-1B pars. 5-91, 5-92, 5-96; table 5-1
Radiography (X-ray)Internal flaws, hidden areas, water in honeycomb core, crushed core; gives a permanent recordCracks only when nearly along the beam; tight cracks in thick sections; delaminations almost never; no depth; radiation hazardMost; composites need low energyAC 43.13-1B pars. 5-80, 5-81, 5-83; FAA-H-8083-31B p. 7-18
ThermographyDebonds, cracks, impact damage, panel thinning, water in composites and honeycombWorks best on thin laminates and near-surface flawsComposite and bonded structureAC 43.13-1B par. 5-120; FAA-H-8083-31B p. 7-18

AC 43.13-1B also lists acoustic emission, holography and shearography (pars. 5-112 to 5-134). The inspection document names the method; this table is for understanding it, not for choosing a different one.

What each method sees

Eight panels. 1 Visual: flashlight beam 5° to 45° to the surface, toward the face, over a crack. 2 Liquid penetrant: dye in an open crack bleeds into the developer; a flaw below the surface is missed. 3 Magnetic particle: particles gather at a crack across the field; a crack along the field is missed. 4 Eddy current: probe over a crack at a fastener hole; 100 Hz to 200 kHz for surface cracks, 100 Hz to 40 kHz for corrosion. 5 Ultrasonic: pulse-echo screen with pulse, flaw and backwall echoes; 0.5 to 15 MHz. 6 Radiography: a crack along the beam shows on the film, one across it does not; portable tube about 300 keV. 7 Tap test: hammer of 2 oz at most on skins under .080 in, disbond found, far bondline needs the other side. 8 An indication is judged against the limits of the procedure: within them OK, outside them reject.
Each method sees only what its physics reaches: orientation decides for magnetic particle and X-ray, the open surface for penetrant, the near skin for the tap test. Values from AC 43.13-1B chapter 5; the accept size comes from the procedure, the SRM or the AD.

Who names the method, and what decides it

ItemWhat the sources saySource
Who names the methodThe manufacturer's inspection, maintenance or overhaul manual, an AD, an SSID or an SB. Some ADs refer to SBs that refer to the manualAC 43.13-1B pars. 5-1, 5-6
Another methodOnly with acceptable data, for example procedures developed by a 14 CFR part 145 repair stationAC 43.13-1B par. 5-1
FactorsHow critical the part is; material, size, shape and weight; flaw sought; acceptable flaw size; where and how flaws lie; access; number of partsAC 43.13-1B par. 5-6 b
SensitivityA part that cannot tolerate a small flaw needs a more sensitive methodAC 43.13-1B par. 5-6 c
ConfirmationOne inspection may show a possible flaw and another confirm it. Visual inspection often confirms flaws found by other methodsAC 43.13-1B pars. 5-6 a, 5-15

Table 5-1 is a guide for choosing only when neither the manufacturer nor the FAA has specified a method (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-6 e).

Who may do it: NDT qualification

Level or ruleWhat it asksSource
Level I SpecialClassroom hours and on-the-job training for one specific task; vision and color-perception test; a general and a practical exam set by a Level II or IIIAC 43.13-1B par. 5-3 a (ATA Spec 105)
Level I / Level IIAn FAA airframe and powerplant certificate, the formal classroom hours and an exam: the certificate is the entry, not the qualificationAC 43.13-1B par. 5-3 b
Level IIIEngineering or science degree and experience as a Level II in the method, or 4 years as a Level II and an examAC 43.13-1B par. 5-3 c
Reading eddy current, X-ray or ultrasonic indicationsQualified and certified to FAA or other accepted standards, such as MIL-STD-410 or ATA Spec 105AC 43.13-1B par. 5-4
EASA Part-145NDT staff qualified to Level 1, 2 or 3 of EN 4179 for the NDT function they performAMC 145.A.30(f) par. 2
Tap testRead by ear, so only qualified personnelAC 43.13-1B par. 5-105 b

The qualification is per method. Who may sign the release after the inspection is a separate question, answered by the organization's approval.

2Allowable damage

Reading an indication

An indication becomes a defect only once it is judged. Each one is evaluated against the acceptable limits of the procedure (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-63 j). Misreading works both ways: a serviceable part rejected, or a defective one accepted (par. 5-5).

Some indications come from the design, not from a flaw. With magnetic particle, sharp radii under 0.10 in [2.5 mm] distort the field (par. 5-41 b). In a tap test, an internal doubler or stiffener changes the pitch on purpose (FAA-H-8083-31B p. 7-15). A known good area, or a standard, is the comparison (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-105).

Orientation decides what can be seen. The magnetic field must cross the expected flaw (par. 5-41 a). A crack shows on film only when it lies nearly along the beam (par. 5-81). Ultrasonic inspection is very sensitive to the angle between beam and flaw (table 5-1). A clean result is only as good as that geometry.

The numbers the public documents give

ItemValue [mm]Source
Flashlight angle for surface cracks5° to 45° to the surface, toward the faceAC 43.13-1B par. 5-18 h(1)
Magnifier to carry / to confirm a crack2 to 10 power / 10 powerAC 43.13-1B pars. 5-16, 5-18 h(1)
Magnification of a simple lensM = 10 / f, f in inches: f = 5 in [127 mm] gives 2 powerAC 43.13-1B par. 5-16 c
Eddy current, surface cracks100 Hz to 200 kHzAC 43.13-1B par. 5-28 a(1)
Eddy current, corrosion100 Hz to 40 kHz; shielded probe, coil 0.15 to 0.5 in [3.8 to 12.7 mm]AC 43.13-1B par. 5-30
Ultrasonic field instrument0.5 to 15 MHzAC 43.13-1B par. 5-93
Tap hammer / skin it works on2 oz [57 g] at most / under 0.080 in [2.0 mm]AC 43.13-1B par. 5-105
Coatings left on for magnetic particlePaint or chrome up to 0.003 in [0.08 mm]; electroplated nickel up to 0.001 in [0.025 mm]AC 43.13-1B par. 5-45 a
Portable X-ray tubeAbout 300 keV; up to the absorption of 3 in [75 mm] of steelAC 43.13-1B par. 5-82
Accept size of an indication—The procedure, the SRM or the AD (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-6 b(4))
Conductivity acceptance (% IACS)—The NDT manual or the material specification

mm values are converted from the inch values of the documents; 75 mm is printed in AC 43.13-1B.

Know the blind side. Penetrant cannot see below the surface, magnetic particle cannot see aluminum, X-ray almost never shows a delamination, and a tap test does not hear the far bondline of a honeycomb panel. When the area or the flaw is outside what the named method can see, report it; do not sign the area as clean.

3Repair

Doing the inspection

StepActionWhat to do
1Get the procedureMethod, area, reference standard and accept limits from the NDT manual, the SB, the AD or the SSID (AC 43.13-1B pars. 5-1, 5-6).
2Look firstGeneral area: cleanliness, foreign objects, deformed or missing fasteners, security, corrosion, damage. Mirror or borescope where the area is hidden (par. 5-18 a).
3Prepare for the methodVisual: clean, but leave the finish on (par. 5-18 g). Penetrant: remove paint, sealant and contaminants; etch where a mechanical process may have closed the openings (pars. 5-62, 5-63 g). Magnetic particle: coatings over the limits off (par. 5-45 a). Eddy current: usually through the coating (par. 5-27).
4CalibrateOn the reference standard the procedure names: same material, with known flaws such as a notch, a fastener hole or a countersink (pars. 5-28 a(3), 5-93).
5Inspect the whole areaScan pattern and speed as written (par. 5-31). In a tap test, tap all of the area of interest (par. 5-105 b).
6Confirm and sizeConfirm a possible flaw by the second inspection the procedure gives; trace the length of a crack (pars. 5-6 a, 5-18 h(1)).
7Clean up and protectRemove penetrant residues (par. 5-63); demagnetize after magnetic particle (table 5-1); restore the finish (see conversion coat and primer).
8RecordSize, shape and location of each discontinuity, rework or disposition; a photo or video helps (par. 5-18 i).

Worked example: three findings, three methods

Three findings on one check. The method in the aircraft's procedure governs each one; this shows why the procedure picks what it picks.

  1. A crack indication at the radius of a 4130 steel fitting. Steel is ferromagnetic, so magnetic particle works if the field is set across the expected crack (AC 43.13-1B pars. 5-40, 5-41 a). Penetrant also works on steel and is generally more sensitive (par. 5-60 a). With magnetic particle: paint over 0.003 in [0.08 mm] off first, demagnetize after.
  2. A suspected crack at a fastener row in a painted 2024-T3 skin. Aluminum is not ferromagnetic, so no magnetic particle. High-frequency eddy current with a pencil or fastener-hole probe works through the paint, on a reference standard of the same alloy (pars. 5-27, 5-28).
  3. A suspected disbond in a 0.040 in [1.0 mm] face sheet of a honeycomb panel. The skin is under 0.080 in [2.0 mm], so a tap test can find a near-side disbond; the far bondline needs the other side, or ultrasonic or thermography (par. 5-105 b; FAA-H-8083-31B p. 7-18).

Magnetic particle or penetrant on the steel fitting, eddy current on the aluminum skin, tap test and then the method the manual gives on the honeycomb. Each result is judged against the manual's limit, not this page.

Safety. Radiography: radiation safety requirements come from the manufacturer's manual, the FAA and the radiation safety authority; keep exposure within safe limits (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-83). Penetrants, developers, removers and particle baths: read the safety data sheet before use (par. 5-6 d).
Syllabus EASA Part-66 Appendix I (as amended by Regulation (EU) 2023/989): 7.18(c) Non-destructive inspection techniques. FAA-S-ACS-1: AM.I.K Inspection Concepts and Techniques.

Quick check

A crack is suspected at a fastener row in a painted 2024-T3 skin. Which method fits first?

  1. Magnetic particle

    Not this one. No: it works only on ferromagnetic iron and steel (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-40).

  2. High-frequency eddy current with a pencil or fastener-hole probe

    Best fit. Yes: the skin conducts, the method finds small local cracks and usually works through the paint (pars. 5-27, 5-28).

  3. Radiography

    Not this one. No: a crack shows only when it lies nearly along the beam, and tight cracks may not show at all (par. 5-81).

On a real job, the SRM decides.

Questions people actually ask

Does my A&P or Part-66 license let me do NDT?

Not by itself. Under ATA Spec 105 the A&P certificate is the entry to Level I/II, with classroom hours and an exam on top (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-3 b). In a Part-145 organization, NDT staff hold an EN 4179 level for the function (AMC 145.A.30(f)). Visual inspection is part of every mechanic's work: about 80 percent of all NDI is visual (par. 5-15).

Do I have to strip the paint for eddy current?

Usually not: eddy current works through primer, paint and anodic films (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-27). The procedure says if the coating must come off.

Can I use penetrant on a surface I have just sanded?

A mechanical process can smear metal over the opening of a crack. Etching removes that thin layer (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-63 g). Follow the procedure for the part.

Why can a tap test pass a bad honeycomb panel?

It hears only near-side defects in skins under 0.080 in [2.0 mm]; the far bondline is not evaluated from one side (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-105 b). The composite damage assessment guide covers the A-scan and thermography that follow.

What is a conductivity test for?

Eddy current conductivity tells the alloy and its heat-treat condition (AC 43.13-1B par. 5-25). After heavy grinding, or any suspected heat damage, a hardness or conductivity test verifies the metal (par. 6-136; TO 1-1A-1 par. 2.1.4, which refers to TO 33B-1-1). The methods are on Testing of materials.

Where can I read more?

AC 43.13-1B par. 5-1 points to AC 43-3, Nondestructive Testing in Aircraft, for more on NDI.

Limits of this guide

What the sources support, and no further.

  • The NDT manual governs. Method, reference standard, scan and accept limits come from the aircraft's NDT manual, the SRM, the SB, the AD or the SSID.
  • No accept sizes and no conductivity values are given: they are part-specific.
  • Overview only: it does not qualify anyone to perform or interpret NDT.
  • Frequencies and settings are the typical ranges printed in AC 43.13-1B, not settings for a given task.
  • mm values are converted from the inch values of the documents.

Where to buy

AmericaDistributor coming soon
EuropeDistributor coming soon
OceaniaDistributor coming soon

Are you a distributor? Get listed →

Distributors coming soon.

Main sources

  • AC 43.13-1B with Change 1, Acceptable Methods, Techniques, and Practices — Aircraft Inspection and Repair — Ch. 5: pars. 5-1, 5-3 to 5-7 and table 5-1; 5-15 to 5-18 (visual, borescope); 5-25 to 5-31 (eddy current); 5-40, 5-41, 5-45 (magnetic particle); 5-60 to 5-63 (penetrant); 5-80 to 5-83 (radiography); 5-91 to 5-96 (ultrasonic); 5-105 (tap test); 5-112 to 5-134 (other methods). Ch. 6: par. 6-136.
  • FAA-H-8083-31B, Aviation Maintenance Technician Handbook — Airframe (2023) — Ch. 7, pp. 7-15 to 7-18: visual inspection, tap test, radiography and thermography of composites.
  • TO 1-1A-1 / NAVAIR 01-1A-1, General Manual for Structural Repair — Par. 2.1.4: hardness or conductivity test after heat damage, to TO 33B-1-1.
  • AMC 145.A.30(f) to Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014, Annex II (Part-145) — Par. 2: appropriately qualified means Level 1, 2 or 3 of EN 4179 for the NDT function performed (ED Decision 2015/029/R; par. 1 amended by ED Decision 2023/013/R).
  • AC 43-3, Nondestructive Testing in Aircraft — Named by AC 43.13-1B par. 5-1 for more on NDI.
  • EASA Part-66 Appendix I (Regulation (EU) 2023/989) and FAA-S-ACS-1 — Module 7.18(c); AM.I.K.

Cross-checked with other manuals and standards in our library.

Educational reference only. Not approved data. Always consult the applicable SRM, AMM, or AC 43.13-1B and your certifying authority.
esc
↑↓ navigate↵ openesc close